KleverStock

Mr D.I.Y.'s growth reset divides research houses

Published 18 November 2026, 04:19 pm Updated 19 November 2026, 04:18 am KleverstockEN
Mr D.I.Y.'s growth reset divides research houses

KUALA LUMPUR: MRDIY is expected to face a challenging operating environment as it shifts its strategy from aggressive store expansion towards improving productivity at existing outlets, with research houses divided over whether the move will be sufficient to revive earnings growth.

CGS International (CGSI) Research sees the retailer's more measured expansion strategy as a positive development that could ease store cannibalisation and support a recovery in same-store sales growth (SSSG). It maintained its 'Add' recommendation, albeit with a lower target price (TP) of RM1.35.

AmInvestment Bank Research (AmBank Research), however, remains cautious, keeping its 'Hold' call and lowering its TP to RM1, as it expects subdued consumer sentiment, intensifying competition and persistent margin pressures to constrain the group's earnings recovery.

The differing assessments come after Mr D.I.Y.'s nine-month financial year 2026 (9M26) results fell short of AmBank Research's expectations but were broadly in line with CGSI Research's forecasts.

CGSI Research said the group's 9M26 core net profit of RM456 million represented 69% of both its full-year forecast and Bloomberg consensus estimates, which it considered satisfactory given that the fourth quarter is seasonally stronger due to festive demand.

AmBank Research, meanwhile, noted that the same earnings figure accounted for only 68% of its and consensus full-year estimates, and viewed the performance as insufficient to support a more positive outlook.

For the third quarter ended Sept 30, 2026 (3Q26), Mr D.I.Y.'s core net profit declined 9% year-on-year (y-o-y) to RM127.3 million, while revenue grew 4.8% to RM1.26 billion.

The revenue increase was supported by a 7% rise in transaction volume to 53 million and contributions from new outlets. However, average basket value declined 2.2% to RM23.71, while SSSG remained negative at 3%, although this was an improvement from negative 3.7% in 2Q26.

Both research houses highlighted weakening store-level performance as a key concern, but differed in their assessment of how quickly the group's strategic changes could address the problem.

CGSI Research believes slower store expansion should reduce cannibalisation between outlets, which has been a major drag on SSSG. It also expects the group's refurbishment programme and loyalty initiatives to improve sales productivity.

"We view the reset positively as a slower rollout should ease cannibalisation, the main drag on SSSG," it said in a note to clients today.

The research house noted that management had lowered its new-store opening target for the financial year ending December (FY26) to 130 from 150, while reducing its annual expansion target for FY27 and FY28 to 70 outlets from 155.

The group has also revised its FY28 store-count target to 1,800 from 2,000 and plans to refurbish between 200 and 250 stores throughout 2026 and 2027.

CGSI Research believes these initiatives could support sales at existing outlets, particularly alongside the MR DIY Club loyalty programme, which has attracted 1.2 million members. It noted that members spend approximately RM36 per visit compared with RM23 for non-members.

The research house also considers the group's valuation attractive following a 32% decline in its share price over the past 12 months. Its revised TP of RM1.35, against RM1.90 previously, incorporates lower earnings assumptions and a reduced long-term growth rate to reflect slower but higher-quality expansion.

At its forecast FY26 price-to-earnings ratio of 15.22 times, CGSI Research estimates a dividend yield of approximately 9% and potential total return of about 39%.

AmBank Research, on the other hand, believes the retailer's challenges extend beyond the pace of store openings, pointing to structural weaknesses in its existing network and mounting competitive pressures.

Although total transaction volume increased 9% to 159 million in 9M26, transactions per store declined 1.2% y-o-y. Average basket size also fell to approximately RM24.40 from RM25.70 a year earlier.

The research house said these figures suggest that initiatives such as store refurbishments, price-lock programmes and larger-format outlets have yet to adequately improve individual store performance.

"Despite a 45% share price correction from Jan-26 highs, we remain cautious as SSSG is likely to stay subdued amid intensifying competition, weak consumer sentiment and mounting margin pressures on an already saturated network," it said.

AmBank Research also highlighted the threat from Chinese retailers expanding into overseas markets, alongside elevated input costs and the anticipated minimum wage increase in mid-2027, as factors that could further pressure margins.

Unlike CGSI Research, which sees the slower rollout as an opportunity to improve store productivity and earnings quality, AmBank Research believes the benefits may take time to materialise against an increasingly competitive operating environment.

Consequently, AmBank Research cut its FY26, FY27 and FY28 earnings forecasts by 8%, 12.6% and 19.4% respectively, while CGSI Research reduced its corresponding earnings-per-share estimates by 3%, 12% and 19%.

Both research houses nevertheless acknowledged the importance of the group's dividend distributions in supporting investor returns. While CGSI Research estimates a higher FY26 dividend yield of approximately 9%, AmBank Research expects yields of between 5% and 6%, providing some downside support.

The contrasting recommendations therefore reflect different assessments of Mr D.I.Y.'s ability to translate its strategic shift into improved financial performance: CGSI Research sees an opportunity for a recovery through better store productivity and attractive valuations, while AmBank Research remains concerned that competitive and cost pressures could outweigh those improvements.