KleverStock

Zen Tech faces uphill battle to find third auditor

Published 18 November 2026, 08:41 am Updated 20 November 2026, 10:17 am KleverstockEN
Zen Tech faces uphill battle to find third auditor

CAN Zen Tech International Bhd get a replacement auditor?

WELL, it all depends on how seriously audit partners across Malaysia take to heart the old saying: "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me."

FOOL me once, shame on you means that if someone tricks or deceives you for the first time, the fault and dishonesty lie with them.

FOOL me twice, shame on me means that if you allow the same person to deceive you a second time in the same way, the responsibility shifts to you for failing to learn from the experience.

THE earliest known written version of this saying appears in Anthony Weldon's 1651 book, The Court and Character of King James, in which he wrote: "The Italians have a Proverb, 'He that deceives me once, it's his fault. He that deceives me twice, it's my fault.'"

SO, how is all this related to Zen Tech in this day and age?

MOST of us may have read that financially distressed Zen Tech, formerly known as the now-infamous Inix Technology Bhd, announced this month that it was parting ways with its external auditors.

INIX Technology Bhd became infamous in the history of Corporate Malaysia when it somehow managed to appoint Chinese national Wan Kuok Koi as its independent non-executive chairman back in 2020.

Wan is better known by his gang moniker, Broken Tooth Koi. He was released from prison in Macau in December 2012 after serving a 14-year sentence for offences including loan-sharking, money laundering and leading a criminal group, according to several news reports.

THE reports were never challenged by Wan, who was reportedly the Dragon Head, or head honcho, of the infamous 14K triad, which operated out of Macau, the former Portuguese colony. It is said that his reach extended across parts of Europe and Southeast Asia.

ZEN Tech's latest issue is the abrupt resignation of its auditors, Morison LC PLT, whose resignation notice was submitted in November 2026 over unpaid audit fees.

MORISON's annual audit fees are estimated to be in the region of RM188,000, an amount that should not be particularly onerous for a publicly listed company.

AN external audit firm will typically issue a written notice of resignation under Section 281 of the Companies Act 2016, citing outstanding audit fees and ethical or independence considerations.

THE resignation takes effect 21 days after the notice is given.

Under Section 284 of the Companies Act 2016 and Bursa Malaysia's listing requirements, the resigning auditor must submit a statement setting out the circumstances connected with its resignation to both the Companies Commission of Malaysia (SSM) and Bursa Malaysia. The listed company is also required to make an immediate public announcement to shareholders.

FOR Zen Tech, however, making such a payment could be a stretch, although it is not entirely impossible if the company is determined to do so.

FOR the six months ended June 30, 2026, Zen Tech had RM47,000 in fixed deposits and an additional RM108,000 in its current account.

FINANCIALLY, however, Zen Tech appeared to be in poor shape, having suffered a pre-tax loss of RM9.9 million for the first half of the year on revenue of RM23.32 million.

WHAT is interesting about the auditors' resignation is the statement Zen Tech made to the stock exchange.

IN its announcement to Bursa Malaysia, Zen Tech stated that the resignation was due to outstanding audit fees and related independence considerations in accordance with professional auditing standards.

THE devil, they say, is always in the detail. And the detail here is that the resignation was attributed to "related independence considerations in accordance with professional auditing standards".

WHAT does that actually mean? According to information obtained with the assistance of artificial intelligence, it could mean that the auditors have taken the position that, because they have not been paid, they do not wish to put themselves in a situation where financial pressure could compromise their independence or influence the audit process, including any efforts to expedite a regularisation plan.

WHY Zen Tech might find it particularly difficult to secure another auditor is that Morison LC PLT was itself appointed as a replacement for Messrs SBY Partners PLT, which had previously served as the company's external auditor.

LIKE its successor, Messrs SBY Partners PLT also resigned from its appointment with Zen Tech over disputes concerning audit fees.

IT could be lights out for Zen Tech even before the regulators consider the merits of any rescue plan, if no audit firm is willing to take a chance on being third time lucky.

Written by Francis Fernandez, a former news editor with Business Times and Malay Mail.
The writer's views expressed here are his own.